26 Comments
User's avatar
Corie Feiner's avatar

“Was it light?

Was it light within?

Was it light within light?”

This series of questions was profoundly moving. I love the idea of the pause and time slowing down enough to ask questions, to be with the light.

Expand full comment
"The Major"'s avatar

I feel since I've been going to gym for first time in 40s ever things have awakened...like winter pause A "lively understandable spirit

Once entertained you.

It will come again.

Be still.

Wait."

Expand full comment
Ethan Summers's avatar

Interesting association of ideas apparently unrelated, the gym and the words of the poem… yet for some reason I resonate with your perspective. When you start on that path it feels like an awakening, a spirit aroused by a multitude of new possibilities... all the energy, fresh, receptive to what life has to offer in ways you were not receptive before, an awareness that the ancient greeks must have had

Expand full comment
"The Major"'s avatar

I try to read the poem and see what images come to mind and that's why hit me thanks

Expand full comment
Mary Roblyn's avatar

This is my absolute favorite Roethke poem. My 1975 Doubleday paperback edition of the Collected Poems has a spine broken in several places and is held together by rubber bands. It is always on my bookshelf, glowing from within. This little poem has seen me through some very dark times. Thank you for sharing it.

Expand full comment
Susanne Floyd Gunter's avatar

What a lovely Sunday morning read! Thanks so much

Expand full comment
Jamie Millard's avatar

Oooh! What came to mind for me was “ all the light we cannot see”!

Expand full comment
Jamie Millard's avatar

"Those who are willing to be vulnerable move among mysteries."

- Roethke

Expand full comment
Donna McArthur's avatar

We get beginning winter where I live.

Wait.

In one glorious day it became full winter very quickly.

Thanks for sharing this beautiful piece.

Expand full comment
Lyn Geist's avatar

"The bones of weeds kept swinging in the wind..." Winter is always beginning here, at least until the day the sun warms the air into early evening. Then it is beginning spring.

The only full season we get in sunny CA is summer. So I find this description beautifully reminiscent of my childhood excitement as I anticipated the first snow of winter in Minnesota.

Expand full comment
Linda Whiteside's avatar

I also felt like I have lived this poem, as a child in rural northwestern Minnesota. Some of the deepest images which remain after 60 years.

Expand full comment
Lyn Geist's avatar

Seems like a whole other world doesn't it? For as much that has changed, some things remain exactly as they were. Like winter's cold.

Expand full comment
Mary Roblyn's avatar

Lyn,

I’ve lived in Minnesota my entire life. You’ve expressed the sacred nature of this beautiful land. This poem embodies it for me. It was written on my heart when I needed it most. I carry it everywhere. And my “lively understandable spirit” has always come again.

Expand full comment
Mary Roblyn's avatar

And Linda. This poem feels like all I need of prayer.

Expand full comment
Frederick Warren's avatar

"Minnesota" sounds, as the ice skates glide upon the frozen pond.

The cross country skiers full exhale from her woolen face mask.

The crisp howl of wind breathing through broken branches.

I'm so lucky to have found this winters respite ...

in Phoenix, Arizona.

I sigh a deep breathe of relief

Expand full comment
Adita del Rosario's avatar

The rain is falling here, and the temperatures are relatively mild, but the winter will appear eventually. Winter, like a luminous grim reaper it will walk out of the plume of fog to collect and store all that has died away. And I look forward to that season of sleep.

A lovely, meditative poem

Expand full comment
Miltiathis Charamis's avatar

One has to succumb to the eventuality of winter.

Expand full comment
My Friend Lisa's avatar

Oh! Nice one. I could read that all day.

Expand full comment
Judy Ertl's avatar

Thank you for this beautiful poem...his ability to paint with language is astounding!

Expand full comment
Kurt Rostek aka Paintguy's avatar

A lot to be said about silence

Expand full comment
Dian Parker's avatar

Lovely.

Expand full comment
Weston Parker's avatar

Dian, I want to lure you over to my substack to be a reader. I posted this poem today.https://westonpparker.substack.com/p/the-home

and another essay about building which may not be your cup of tea.

Expand full comment
Robert Walrod's avatar

Huge Roethke fan.

Expand full comment
Miltiathis Charamis's avatar

Was it light? / Was it light within? / Was it light within light?” It's a moment of revelation—the moment you and the universe become one - but only for a moment.What a way to say it!

Expand full comment
Daniel Buecher's avatar

Ahhhhh❤️

Expand full comment
Weston Parker's avatar

a very evocative poem, best kind.

Expand full comment