39 Comments
User's avatar
Norm's avatar

We have been archiving all the tapes from Babar, and some of the other associated readings. It's a slow process, getting them at the correct quality with all the noise, inconsistency, etc, but could keep you posted as things get remastered and brought back to life. Let me know.

Expand full comment
Bruce Isaacson's avatar

Here is a recording of Julia reading this poem at Cafe Babar, June 23, 1988

https://www.zeitgeist-press.com/index.php/authors/julia-vinograd/

Expand full comment
Bruce Isaacson's avatar

I believe there is a recording in the set of Julia reading this poem. Will see what we can do about posting it somewhere.

Expand full comment
Kim Nelson's avatar

Ha! Yes! I sometimes feel this way while in a class or workshop dissecting the poem of yet another well-intended -- even talented -- writer.

Expand full comment
Musho Rodney Greenblat's avatar

Society has an inane urge to explain art and poetry. If only they could just feel it. Thank you Julia Vinograd. Stay fierce.

Expand full comment
Ken Paul Rosenthal's avatar

Thankyou Erik for re-posting this poem along with Patti Smith's fine recitation. As the director of the in-progress feature documentary about Julia's life and legacy, I'd like to inform everyone that I'm aiming for a Spring 2026 completion, contingent on funding. I will be offering sneak-peak previews for any donation amount--past or future--later this summer. Please join the film mailing list to keep apprised. Lastly, I've produced a brand-new collection of my 28 most cherished Julia Vinograd poems, lovingly selected from her entire oeuvre and brimming with archival photos of Julia and intimate close-ups of her typewriter's mechanical interior. This e-book, like the film, is a balm for our brokenness and a testament to Vinograd's indefatigable commitment to her craft. Please give to the documentary about the woman who gave by ordering your 'Of Spirit and Stone' e-book today. More info here: https://www.betweenspiritandstonethefilm.com/support/merch/

Expand full comment
Lovleigh's avatar

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 Brava!

Expand full comment
Andrea Stoeckel's avatar

"...Some of a poet’s work comes from his life, ok.

But most of a poet’s work comes

in spite of his life, in spite of everything,

even in spite of bookstores.."

Expand full comment
Sam Quinones's avatar

Thoughtful poem. I remember the Bubble Lady, who was often on Telegraph Ave when I was in college at Berkeley (1977-82), frequently at the Cafe Med as well. She seemed like a nice sort, always blowing bubbles. I think it took me a while to realize she was a poet. At least, it wasn't the first thing I knew about her....I may have read some of her poems around that time, though it's been so long that I couldn't swear to it.....I was sorry to hear she had passed.

Expand full comment
Bruce Isaacson's avatar

"So you don’t have to waste your time

on the best the writer could do,

the words he fought the darkness and himself for,

the unequal battle with beauty."

These lines are some of Julia's best writing. Her Selected Works was almost titled "the unequal battle with beauty" but standing on its own it seemed pretentious, and Julie was never pretentious. But a great line, especially in the context of this poem. In 1989, our friend David Lerner called me up all agog having rediscovered and found himself in love with Julia's poetry from this line and poem.

Expand full comment
Alastair Muirhead's avatar

It’s a bit like a Cupcake, if you fancy the real thing you wouldn’t go to the book shop to buy a picture book on Cupcakes.

Expand full comment
Chris Gartland's avatar

I hope the documentary isn't too much like the books in the bookstore.

Expand full comment
cal lash's avatar

I read poetry to borrow great words to inhabit my philosophy.

And I offer a quote:

"In my work, as a writer, I only photograph, in words, what I see."

Charles Bukowoski

Expand full comment
Francis DiClemente's avatar

Devastating poem! Thanks for sharing.

Expand full comment
Colette Letourneau's avatar

I had to analyze poetry for one of my literature classes and always felt guilty and dirty. I complained to my professor that it felt like ‘dissecting an angel’.

Expand full comment
Hal Davis's avatar

I came across a stapled volume of her poems at Chicago House in Austin, Texas. Charmed, I snaffled it. (I sent a replacement copy.) Decades later, I came across another of her poems, and paid way over cover price for her latest volume, with a letter of thanks.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

That's awesome!

Expand full comment
garrick's avatar

Recently found her work and got one of her books. Great stuff and I'm getting another. Good to hear of a documentary on her, would love to see it and hope it gets released. Another poet I think would make a great movie or documentary is Anna Akhmatova. She had a very tumultuous life living through WWI, WWII, Stalin, gulags and constant govt pressure to conform.

Expand full comment